Four SERP APIs return real URLs again, Bright Data still does not
Summary
The SERP API wrapper problem is now mostly fixed on the provider side, with Bright Data the holdout, while Google itself still serves the google.com/goto redirects.
Count wrapped links in this week's own pull, split by provider, country and device, before trusting the rankings in it.
A re-measurement on 7 November found four of five SERP APIs, the services rank trackers use to pull Google results, returning real organic URLs again instead of google.com/goto redirect wrappers. The Part 3 post in r/TechSEO, from Reddit user u/DrKJING, who ran the two earlier rounds, re-sent the same 50 desktop queries to each provider and counted unresolved links in the raw responses. Bright Data was the exception, at 86.8% of its organic results.
A week ago the fix was the same whoever you bought data from: audit your SERP export for wrapper URLs and convert whatever came back wrapped, because a wrapped link leaves your own domain missing or unattributed in the export. Four providers have since done that work on their side.
| Provider | Oct 31 | Nov 7 |
|---|---|---|
| DataForSEO (standard queue) | 63.3% | 0.0% |
| SerpApi | 85.1% | 0.0% |
| Serper | 42.6% | 0.0% |
| Oxylabs | 71.8% | 1.9% |
| Bright Data | 74.1% | 86.8% |
Share of organic results with no real URL, German and US desktop queries.
Google has not stopped serving the wrappers. All 20 HTML pages u/DrKJING pulled through DataForSEO still contained them, so what moved is what the APIs hand back, and it can move again without an announcement. A provider-side change like that arrives in a dashboard looking like ranking movement, the way scraper blocking looked like a visibility drop in September.
DataForSEO’s support wrote to u/DrKJING on 6 November that its standard queue now resolves all goto URLs. A separate daily check on the same queue agrees: around 60% of links came back wrapped through 4 November. Since 6 November, none have. The company’s goto_url_converter, which it had called a dedicated solution for this in an earlier reply, resolved 122 of 122 links with the domain matching every time, at no cost. Both of those results describe the standard queue, so an integration calling a different DataForSEO queue needs its own check before the zero applies to it.
Oxylabs and Serper, the two providers not at zero everywhere, miss real URLs only in narrow places. Oxylabs’ eight unresolved results in German and US desktop all sat on one US page. Serper was clean on the 50 German and US queries but not in Europe. There 19 of 1,050 results came back unresolved, on a handful of pages in Italy and Poland. Serper reported on 6 November that Google had tightened its limits again, and that queries carrying operators like site: now get only their top three results resolved; u/DrKJING’s queries used no operators, so those European pages stay unexplained. Any tracking built on site: queries needs measuring on its own rather than reading across from these figures.
The sample is hand-picked queries at single points in time, with no provider comparison between 3 and 7 November. The stronger reason not to treat 7 November as settled is in the table: several providers moved tens of percentage points within days, and Bright Data moved the wrong way.
What to do
- Count wrappers in the pull you have now, not last week’s. Split the count by provider, country and device, since Serper was at zero on German and US desktop while returning wrapped links in Italy and Poland.
- On Bright Data, keep resolving links before any report goes out. The 31 October advice still applies there, and only there.
- On DataForSEO, confirm which queue your integration calls, then spot-check that queue’s raw
linkfield. The converter costs nothing, so running the wrapped links through it is a request, not a budget decision. - Treat client visibility changes dated from 30 October onward as unverified until the wrapper share for that provider and country is known for those days. A domain that vanished from a tracker in that window is as likely to be a missing URL as a lost position.
- Check the raw link rather than the display domain. In the 31 October round the display line still showed a readable domain for 91 to 99% of unresolved results, so a report can look correct while the underlying URL is a redirect.