AI Overviews and ChatGPT usually criticize different brands
Summary
Brand criticism in AI answers is rare, but Google and ChatGPT find it in different places. Google's answers pick up news about lawsuits and recalls. ChatGPT's answers point out what a product cannot do.
A clean result in one engine says little about the other. Run the same research prompts in both. Check news coverage for Google and product documentation for ChatGPT, and repeat the checks on a schedule.
Google’s AI Overviews and ChatGPT both criticize brands rarely, but they do it for different reasons and mostly aim at different brands. BrightEdge, which sells enterprise SEO software, published a comparison of brand criticism in Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT on February 19, 2026. On overlapping negative prompts, it found the two engines “disagreed on which brand to flag 73% of the time.” When both answered the same question and criticized a brand, they usually criticized different ones. The study covered prompts in apparel, electronics and education.
Negative mentions are uncommon in both engines. BrightEdge counted 2.3% of brand mentions in AI Overviews as negative, against 1.6% in ChatGPT. Google’s rate is higher, but both engines lean heavily positive.
The reasons for going negative differ more than the rates. BrightEdge likens AI Overviews to an investigative reporter and ChatGPT to a product advisor. AI Overviews is 4.5 times more likely than ChatGPT to surface negative sentiment tied to news and controversy, such as lawsuits and recalls. ChatGPT is 3 times more likely than Google to go negative on product evaluation questions, where it points out limitations and compatibility problems.
Most criticism comes from news and product limits
BrightEdge also sorted the negative mentions in its data by what set them off:
| Trigger | Share of negative mentions |
|---|---|
| Brand controversies and legal issues | 32% |
| Product limitations and compatibility | 21% |
| Safety and recalls | 17% |
| Competitive comparisons | 3% |
The small share for comparisons cuts against a sponsored Search Engine Journal post paid for by Erase.com, a reputation management firm. The post centers on comparison queries such as “which CRM should I choose”, which it says can return Reddit gripes and old forum threads about the brands being compared. Its headline promises data, but the post only refers to a “Q1 2026 analysis” and publishes no figures.
The post’s broader claim is that AI answers pull complaints into queries where nobody asked about problems, and BrightEdge’s numbers support it. Negative mentions cluster in informational queries, where people research before deciding: 85.1% of Google’s negatives and 68.5% of ChatGPT’s fell in that phase. Someone asking which tool to pick is not asking for complaints and still gets some. Comparison queries do carry complaints, but the larger exposure comes from news about the brand and from real product limits.
What to do
Nothing on your own domain controls what AI search bots such as OAI-SearchBot or Googlebot retrieve from Reddit or Trustpilot, so robots.txt changes will not help. Google has also been adding more link types, including discussion previews, to its AI answers, which puts forum threads closer to the answer itself. The work happens on third-party content and on the facts you publish.
- Audit each engine separately. With the two disagreeing on most flagged brands, a clean ChatGPT answer says little about AI Overviews. Run the same informational and comparison prompts in both and record which brand each one criticizes. The sponsored post suggests a starter prompt: “What are the pros and cons of [your brand] vs [top competitor]?”
- Match the check to the engine. For AI Overviews, look for news coverage of lawsuits, recalls and outages involving your brand. For ChatGPT, look at how your product’s limits and compatibility are described. BrightEdge does not test fixes, but the likelier remedy for the ChatGPT pattern is plain, accurate documentation of what the product does and does not support.
- Request removal only where a platform’s policy is broken. The sponsored post names false information, impersonation and harassment as grounds, and concedes that removal usually is not an option for a thread that compares five tools and gives one brand a single negative mention. Reply to legitimate complaints with facts and a resolution, since the post notes AI engines can pull a brand’s response into the summary.
- Re-run the prompts on a schedule. BrightEdge found negativity in about 2% of mentions, so a single check can easily miss it.