AI Overviews cut clicks on three of five sites in France

Chart from Google AI Overviews Roll Out In France: GSC Data Reveals The Impact (GSQI)
Chart: Google AI Overviews Roll Out In France, "GSC Data Reveals The Impact (GSQI)"

Summary

The France AI Overviews launch cut clicks on three of the five sites in SEO consultant Glenn Gabe's Search Console data, and the other two held their clicks.

Filter the performance report to France and compare clicks and CTR either side of 22 July before trusting any site-wide estimate of AI Overviews losses.

Google launched AI Overviews and AI Mode in France on 22 July 2026, and on three of the five sites in SEO consultant Glenn Gabe’s Search Console analysis, clicks dropped the same day. The other two held their clicks.

A launch confined to one country, on a date Google published, gives the before and after that most AI Overviews impact claims lack. Ahrefs published panel data on the same rollout in September, covered here as French sites lost CTR in proportion to their AI Overview exposure. Gabe’s post adds what single sites look like inside Search Console. He filtered the performance report to France, used the generative AI report to confirm that impressions from Google’s AI experiences surged on 22 July, then switched to the web search report with the France filter still applied and compared clicks, impressions, CTR and average position either side of that date. That generative AI report covers AI Overviews and AI Mode together, so it dates the launch rather than showing which feature took the clicks.

The hardest-hit site kept its rankings and lost the click. Its web search impressions stayed flat while CTR and daily clicks each fell by almost half overnight. Across the five sites:

SiteClicksCTR
First siteabout 750/day to about 400/day2% to 1.1%
Second site (YMYL)about 80/day to about 25/daystable, because impressions fell too
Third site (YMYL)dropped at launch, again around 13 August1.2% to 0.4%
Fourth and fifth sitesno dropstable

Both YMYL sites, Google’s shorthand for health, finance and similar sensitive topics, stepped down twice: once at launch and again around 10 to 13 August. Gabe reads the second drop as Google extending AI Overviews to query types it held back on 22 July, having been more cautious with sensitive queries first. Whatever the cause, a comparison run in the first two weeks understates the loss on health and finance queries.

The two sites that held steady also saw generative AI impressions surge on 22 July. Being cited in AI Overviews therefore says nothing on its own about whether clicks survive. The generative AI report works as a date stamp. The damage shows only in web search clicks and CTR.

Average position moved on 22 July on almost every site Gabe looked at, including the ones that lost nothing. His explanation is a measurement mechanic rather than a ranking change: a citation in an AI Overview registers an impression only when it is visible, and AI Overviews are collapsed by default, so the citation logs an impression only when someone expands the panel. When the same page also ranks in the ten blue links, that listing logs the impression instead, at a lower position. A position change on the launch date says how the panel is being counted, and acting on it means chasing a rank loss that did not happen.

Two of the dips in Gabe’s data do not belong to the launch at all. One site’s impressions fell about a week before 22 July, in other countries as well, and traffic in some of those countries went up over the same stretch. Another site’s CTR dipped earlier in July and recovered to its previous level. Anchoring the comparison on the exact launch date, rather than on the month, is what separates the feature’s effect from a site’s own noise.

What to do

  • Filter the performance report to France, compare the weeks either side of 22 July 2026, then break the difference down by query. Branded and navigational queries carry higher CTRs than the rest, so compare like with like.
  • Extend the after-window past mid-August. On YMYL queries the first fortnight missed a second drop.
  • Read clicks and impressions before reading CTR. Flat impressions with falling clicks is the AI Overviews pattern. Falling impressions is a separate problem that can hold CTR steady even as clicks fall by two thirds.
  • Ignore average position for this question.
  • Check the same dates in other countries. The pre-launch impression dip on Gabe’s second site showed up outside France too, which marked it as unrelated to the launch.
  • Search the queries that lost clicks and note whether the AI Overview is collapsed or expanded by default. Google began expanding some by default in late August, and an expanded panel pushes the blue links much further down.
  • Check the same weeks in the previous year. A site that normally gains traffic in autumn can show flat numbers that hide a loss.
  • Before using the AI Overviews opt-out, note that blocking the feature also cost regular organic clicks in one test.