Google counts AI Overview clicks inside your total Search clicks
Summary
Ziff Davis set 2.7 billion AI Overview and AI Mode impressions against all its Google Search clicks, but the ratio is not a click-through rate because Google counts AI clicks inside the Search total.
Report AI impressions as a visibility figure and compare them only with your own site's prior periods.
Ziff Davis, the publisher behind IGN and the RetailMeNot app, said organic Google referrals to its properties fell about 37% year over year in the third quarter. CEO Vivek Shah gave the figure to analysts on the company’s Nov. 6 earnings call, per Search Engine Journal’s report. Referrals had fallen about 23% in the same quarter a year earlier, he said, putting the two-year decline above 50%.
Shah said Ziff Davis is “not planning on a search recovery” and expects referrals to keep falling. The number he put next to that came from Search Console: the company’s digital media sites generated about 2.7 billion impressions across AI Overviews and AI Mode during the quarter, nearly 10 times the clicks those same sites received from Google Search, on his estimates. He did not say where the click total came from.
No AI click number exists yet
Search Console does not report AI clicks separately. A click on a link inside an AI Overview or AI Mode lands in a site’s total Search clicks alongside every other result type, and as of Nov. 8 Google documents no separate AI click figure. The impressions side is narrower. The generative AI report counts the times links to a site appeared in those two features, and it draws them from the same Web search data as the main Performance report, so AI impressions are a slice of total Search impressions rather than a parallel measure.
Search Engine Journal’s piece says the consequence plainly: because AI clicks are bundled in with the rest, the ratio cannot be used as an AI click-through rate. The 2.7 billion figure measures visibility, how often Google showed a link to these sites inside its AI features. It says nothing about what that visibility earned. Google has itself started describing AI Mode and classic results as one product, which fits click data that arrives merged.
Every site with the generative AI report can rebuild Shah’s comparison in a few minutes, and a large publisher’s ratio sitting beside a client’s own makes a tempting slide. It is wrong twice over. The denominator carries all of Search, so the ratio is not a rate for any single surface. And two publishers’ query mixes are not comparable anyway. Movement in a site’s own AI impressions, period over period, is the only part of this that behaves like a metric.
The UK’s Competition and Markets Authority has set a Dec. 3 deadline for Google to give publishers impressions, clicks and click-through rate for AI search features in the UK, aggregated across AI Overviews and AI Mode. If Google separates AI clicks from the rest of Search there, publishers get the number Shah did not have. OpenAI is separately building impression and click charts into ChatGPT, so publishers may soon see both halves from more than one platform.
What to do
- Label AI impressions as visibility wherever they appear in client or board reporting. Google publishes no AI click count, so any “AI CTR” on a slide is one surface divided by a Search-wide denominator.
- Track your own AI impressions period over period instead of against another publisher’s ratio, and keep the comparison inside one property.
- Watch what Google ships around Dec. 3. If AI clicks arrive split out from the rest of Search, the comparison becomes real for UK data; if they arrive aggregated with everything else, nothing about today’s reporting changes.