ChatGPT's default model cites brand sites far less than Thinking

Chart from Writesonic: ChatGPT citation study, GPT-5.4 vs GPT-5.3
Chart: Writesonic, "ChatGPT citation study, GPT-5.4 vs GPT-5.3"

Summary

Brand websites got 8% of the citations from ChatGPT's default model, which mostly cited review sites and publications, so a brand's visibility depends on which model a buyer uses.

Test both models in any AI visibility audit, since a good result in one predicts almost nothing about the other.

Two ChatGPT models cite almost entirely different sources for the same question, according to a citation study by Writesonic, an AI content software company. Brand websites got 8% of the default model’s citations and 56% of the Thinking model’s.

The models were GPT-5.3 Instant, ChatGPT’s default at the time, and GPT-5.4 Thinking, its premium reasoning model. For any single prompt, the sources the two models cited overlapped by 7% on average.

Samanyou Garg, Writesonic’s founder, ran 50 prompts and exported each conversation’s JSON through ChatGPT’s internal API. The export showed every search query the model sent and every URL it cited. Citations were sorted into first-party (the brand’s own site, such as hubspot.com for HubSpot) and third-party (review sites, blogs, Reddit, media outlets).

The default model cites whoever reviewed the brand

On product and comparison prompts, the default model mostly cited pages written about the brands rather than by them. Three of the study’s prompts show the gap:

PromptDefault model citedThinking model cited
Best CRM for B2B SaaSdesignrevision.com, techradar.comhubspot.com, salesforce.com, attio.com
Marathon running shoesirunfar.com, reddit.comnike.com, asics.com, hoka.com
SEO toolsapricornsolutions.com, morningscore.ioahrefs.com, semrush.com, screamingfrog.co.uk

Forbes was the default model’s most-cited domain, followed by TechRadar and Tom’s Guide. On “X vs Y vs Z” comparison prompts, the default model never cited a brand’s own site. Writesonic concludes that a product those outlets have not covered is probably invisible to the default model.

The Thinking model checks the brand first

The gap comes from how each model searches. The default model sent one query per prompt: the user’s own words. The Thinking model broke each prompt into 8.5 sub-queries on average, and many of them were limited to named domains or used the site: operator.

For an email marketing prompt, the Thinking model first searched klaviyo.com, omnisend.com and mailchimp.com directly, with queries such as site:klaviyo.com pricing email marketing sms ecommerce 2026. Only after that did it look for outside confirmation on G2 and the Shopify app store. Writesonic calls this a consistent two-phase pattern: brand verification first, third-party validation second. Pricing pages were a frequent landing spot, making up 138 of the Thinking model’s 739 citations.

Writesonic ran the test from a single account based in India, and ChatGPT can answer the same prompt differently on a second run, so the exact percentages will move. The direction is the useful part: a good result in one model predicts almost nothing about the other.

What to do

  • Test both models. On 22 of the 50 prompts the two models shared no cited source at all, so an AI visibility audit run only on the default model misses most of what the Thinking model shows.
  • Earn coverage for the default model. For that model, mentions on the review sites and publications it cites in your category matter more than anything on your own domain. Writesonic also recommends complete G2 and Capterra profiles, which the Thinking model checks after the brand site.
  • Make the pages the Thinking model visits answer the question on the page. Pricing, plan and product pages should state what a buyer asks about. Earlier research found AI search often cites retailers’ size guides and return policies, which points the same way.
  • Keep OAI-SearchBot allowed in robots.txt. Log analysis by Botify, an enterprise SEO platform, describes it as OpenAI’s web search crawler, separate from GPTBot, which collects training data. Writesonic did not test crawler access, but a site that ChatGPT’s search cannot reach gives those site: queries nothing to return.
  • Segment ChatGPT referrals in GA4 by utm_source=chatgpt.com, as Writesonic suggests, to see which pages the citations actually send people to.